Carroll Gardens Fish Market

New York fishmongers on this page spread thin across the five boroughs rather than clustering in one seafood corridor. Zips like 10474, 11212, 11216, 11221, and 11226 each show 3 listings, while 10002, 10013, and 10455 show 2 apiece, so call two or three near your zip instead of assuming one neighborhood has them all. In total, 112 fishmongers are listed for New York, and 109 of those have a phone number attached, so calling ahead to check today's catch is realistic for nearly all of them.

Only 77 listings include a website, which means plenty of shops run on foot traffic and phone orders alone. Paid placements aren't part of this category yet, so any future promoted spot will say Sponsored right on the entry, and nothing here is ranked or picked as a favorite by SiteCity. If you manage one of these New York fishmongers and the hours or contact info are off, you can claim the listing and correct it, so someone hunting for fresh fish tonight doesn't end up at a locked door.