Cortelyou Market by Key Food

SiteCity has 6,471 grocery stores on file in New York. A phone number is attached to 3,947 of those records and a website to 2,248, so for a large share of these stores a call is the only way to ask whether something is in stock before you walk over.

Where they sit is flat rather than clustered. The busiest ZIP is 11368 with 35 stores; 11373 has 28; 11372 and 10002 tie at 26. Against 6,471 listings that is a very even spread. The practical effect is that the ZIP filter narrows this list far less than it would in a category that bunches into one district, so an address search will get you somewhere faster. Sponsored placements carry a Sponsored label wherever they turn up in the results. Owners can claim a store listing and correct the phone number or website on it.