Grilled Cheese Society

New York sandwich shops on SiteCity spread across the city's ZIP codes rather than clustering in one spot. ZIPs 10017 and 10018 each carry 23 listings, 10003 has 22, and 10022 follows close behind with 21, so Midtown and nearby blocks show up often if you're scanning by area. Out of 937 total listings for this category, 860 list a phone number and 840 list a website, giving you a way to call ahead or check a menu before you go.

None of these entries are marked Sponsored right now, so what you're browsing reflects what's on file rather than a paid placement, and any future paid row will say Sponsored directly on it so it's easy to spot. If you manage one of these shops and the phone number, address, or website looks outdated, you can claim the listing and update it yourself instead of waiting for someone else to flag it. Use the ZIP breakdown to narrow your search to a neighborhood, then call two or three spots directly to check hours or ask about today's specials before heading out.