La Rotonda Ristorante

New York lists 2,928 pizza restaurants, and this is one category where the contact details hold up: 2,829 carry a phone number and 2,542 carry a website. A counter that answers the phone will usually tell you whether the oven is still on at eleven, which is a question no listing page can answer for you.

The counts follow foot traffic rather than the residential map. ZIP 10003 has 55 listings; 10002 has 47; 10036 has 44. Filtering to one of those gets you a walkable set instead of a borough-wide scroll. Rows marked Sponsored are paid placements and carry that label wherever they appear; the rest of the order is not for sale. If you run a pizzeria in the city, claim the listing and correct whatever it gets wrong.