Salvatore Iacono: Allstate Insurance

New York's auto insurance listings cluster in a few ZIP codes worth knowing before you start dialing. ZIP 11354 has 6 entries, the most of any area, while 10001, 10016, 10314, 10801, 11103, 11209, and 11377 each carry 4. If you live near one of those ZIPs, you'll likely find several agents within a short drive, so call two or three and compare what they quote before picking up the phone for a fourth. Out of 186 total listings citywide, 185 have a phone number on file and 160 have a website, so most entries give you more than one way to reach out.

None of these listings are marked verified, and this category currently runs zero Sponsored placements, so paid spots are labeled Sponsored whenever they appear and nothing here is promoted or ranked above anything else. If you own an agency listed here and the address or contact details are stale, you can claim the listing and fix it, which matters most in dense ZIPs like 11354 where a wrong number sends a caller straight to a competitor instead. Browse by ZIP, check a few sites first, then call.