International Gold Star, Inc.

New York carries 469 butcher shop listings in this directory, spread across the city's ZIP codes. The heaviest concentration sits in 10014 with 7 shops, followed by 10002, 10474, 11372, and 11385 tied at 6 each. If you're near one of those areas, start there and call two or three to compare cuts, hours, and whether they take special orders. Outside those ZIPs, shops are thinner on the ground, so a quick search by your own ZIP is worth doing before you drive across town.

Contact info here is mostly solid: 447 listings show a phone number and 236 have a website link, so you can usually call ahead or check a site before showing up. Paid placements are labeled Sponsored on this page, and none are running in this category right now, so what you're browsing is the plain, unranked list rather than anything bought. If you run one of these shops and the number or web link is wrong, you can claim the listing yourself and fix it, which helps the next New York shopper trying to reach you.