Toy Store
New York
311 businesses listed, showing 1–40. How we order them.
Most of the 311 toy stores listed for New York come with a working phone number attached, 273 of them, so ringing ahead about stock or hours is realistic rather than a shot in the dark. Fewer, 227, list a website, which means checking hours or browsing inventory online won't always be an option, and calling stays the faster route for a lot of these shops. Scan a listing for both a number and a site before you plan a trip, and call two or three if you're comparing options in the same neighborhood.
More about toy store in New York ↓ ↑
Sponsored tags flag paid placement on SiteCity, and none show up in this category yet, so the order here reflects plain directory records rather than any promoted spot. If you run one of these toy stores and a number's wrong or a website link is dead, you can claim the listing and fix the details yourself, which saves a New York parent a wasted trip before a birthday or holiday rush.
Toy Store in New York by the numbers
SiteCity lists 311 businesses under Toy Store in New York, NY, as of November 4, 2026. 273 list a phone number and 227 list a website.
Most-listed ZIP codes: 10001 (14), 10013 (12) and 11201 (10).
Listings come from Overture Maps Foundation places data (release 2026-08-19.0, which includes Foursquare OS Places) and from businesses added or updated through SiteCity. How we count.
Listings40
- LEGO
200 5th Ave, 10010
- LEGO
2655 Richmond Ave Unit 1285, 10314
- J & L Game
1026 6th Ave, 10018-5418
- Learning Express Toys
1071 3rd Ave, 10065
- GameStop
34 Graham Ave, 11206-4008
- Mini Jake
178 N 9th St, 11211
- Two Kids and A Dog
65 Pearl St, 11201-1147
- Runnin' Wild Kids
349 Court St, 11231-4332
- S&D Kids
1480 Rockaway Pkwy, 11236-3714
- GameStop
25301 ROCKAWAY BLVD STE 11, 11422
- Five Below
34-41 48th Street, 11101
- Tom Dick and Harry Sneakers
1934 3rd Ave, 10029
- Five Below
262 Atlantic Ave, 11201
- Red Caboose
23 W 45th St, 10036-4900
- Five Below
607 6th Avenue, 10011
- Go! Calendars, Toys & Games
2655 Richmond Ave 5533, 10314
- Heart To Heart
9006 3rd Ave #1, 11209
- Party City
625 Atlantic Ave, 11217
- Five Below
954 Pennsylvania Ave, 11207
- Sneakouts
2340 Bath Ave, 11214
- Nintendo NEW YORK
10 Rockefeller Plaza, 10020
- myplasticheart
60 West St Unit 102, 11222
- Brooklyn Superhero Supply Co.
372 5th Ave, 11215
- Brooklyn Video Games
6801 20th Ave, 11204-4566
- CAMP, A Family Experience Store
110 5th Ave, 10011
- Unbox
712 3rd Ave, 11232-1113
- Elizabeth Center
13 Elizabeth St, 10013
- Last Place On Earth
531 Graham Ave, 11222
- Double Play Toys
4115 14th Ave, 11219
- Toys & Bags
28-45 Steinway St, 11103
- Island Hobby Nut
96-09 Metropolitan Ave, 11375
- American Girl Doll 5th Ave NYC
609 5th Ave, 10017
- Brooklyn Hobbies
3852 Flatlands Ave, 11234
- Videogamesnewyork
202 E 6th St, 10003
- Tannen's Magic
45 W 34th St. #608, 10001
- POPnGAMES
12-40 Clintonville St Unit b, 11357
- Exit9 Gift Emporium
51 Avenue A, 10009-7324
- Clever Monsters
1780 Sheepshead Bay Rd, 11235
- My Little Sunshine Kids Store
145 Hudson St, 10013
- Build-A-Bear Workshop
45 Rockefeller Plaza, 10112
Is your business missing here?
Listing is free. Add it and it appears in Toy Store for New York once it passes review.
Add your business